James McNeill Whistler

Whistler, Drury Lane, etching, 1880-1881

Drury Lane

Kennedy 237, Mansfield, 234, Glasgow 243

etching , 1880-1881, a superb impression, the first (and only) state, cleanly and crisply printed in black with fine uniform plate tone, on very thin, 18th-century buff laid paper, with thread margins, some quite localized crimping along the left and bottom margins, with old hinges on the upper sheet edge, verso, otherwise in excellent condition

P. 161 x 101 mm., S.  163 x 103 mm.

Whistler here again takes up a rather commonplace subject, one of his most favorite: the doorway/shopfront façade.  In England of course, but also in his travels from Paris, to Brussels, Amsterdam and Venice, he tirelessly explored this basic feature of the urban landscape with remarkable perspicacity

This particular street scene is set in London, east of Covent Garden, in Drury Lane, which has long been associated with the theatre of the same name and the surrounding entertainment district.  Its reputation has varied greatly over the years* (it is in fact the setting of Hogarth's celebrated 18th-century etching series, A Harlot's Progress), but in Whistler's time it was rather forlorn. **

The etching style is spare, sure, and alert, with no added drypoint retouching (only one state known), with a sense of depth given through the portal resulting from rather sophisticated biting, the extremely fine lines in the far background here showing in great detail.  In the early 1880s, Whistler drew the London etchings directly from life: as Katherine Lochnan notes (in The Etchings of James McNeill Whistler, 1984, p. 223), "He carried around grounded copper plates and used them as a convenient surface for the jotting down of visual impressions as if they were sheets in a sketchbiook."

This print was included in A Set of Twenty-Six Etchings, published by  Messrs Dowdeswell and Thibaudeau in 1886, and printed by the artist:

When Whistler was satisfied with this etching, he sent the copper plates to the publishers, who arranged for a selection to be printed by Émile Frédéric Salmon (1840-1913) for Messrs Dowdeswell, including Drury Lane. However, Whistler then decided to print them himself. ***

The cover sheet for this edition mentions:


According to the correspondence between Whistler and Dowdeswell:

There are numerous dockets, receipts and lists recording the printing and delivery of the edition. Two impressions of Drury Lane were delivered on 2 April, ten on 28 July, four on 25 September 1886; nineteen on 15 January 1887, making a total of 35. ***

The plate was subsequently cancelled.  Glasgow cites 26 known impresssions, but it is also known that impressions of this etching had been exhibited as of 1883, so it is plausible there may be several more. 

At present, it is impossible to ascertain whether the present impression precedes or accompanies the first edition, although the clarity of the finest lines in the far background, as well as the trimming to the edge of the platemark, would in our opinion support the former. 

As it comes from a private Parisian collection, it may also be that, given a small preliminary printing of the plates for this edition by Émile Frédéric Salmon in Paris:

A few impressions were printed in Paris on a paper chosen by A.W. Thibaudeau which W[histler] liked. There had been some talk of the plates being printed in Paris but before the end of the negotiations with Dowdeswell Whistler decided to print himself . ****

An impression from this first trial printing may thus not be ruled out.

See Walter Thornbury, 'Drury Lane Theatre', in Old and New London: Volume 3 (London, 1878), pp. 218-227 on the website http://www.british-history.ac.uk/old-new-london/vol3/pp218-227,  contemporary to Whistler.

**  In 1883, a critic described this etching as "a curious vista view, seen through a gateway, of the dirty, dismal, but not unpicturesque-looking houses of Drury-lane." (Anonymous, 'The Studio. An Arrangement in White and Yellow', in The Queen, 24 February 1883).

***  Glasgow catalogue: http://etchings.arts.gla.ac.uk/catalogue/search/ts_display/index.php?catno=K237&rs=&q=drury+lane&xml=pri

****  Glasgow catalogue: http://etchings.arts.gla.ac.uk/catalogue/sets_texts/?eid=venice2